Experience is something you don't get until just after you need it
Saturday, October 29, 2016
The Dread of Generalist
I am a generalist
and I am scared. I have a new job working back to back with shamelessly good
specialists. I am dreaded not to keep up.
For a long time I
was wondering what is better: to be a specialist or generalist? On the one
hand, specialist is the best in his narrow field. When you need a build, sorry,
DevOps expert, you hire a specialist. You need to solve a Machine Learning
problem, you hire a Machine Learning expert and not some all-around guy! In
addition to having those jobs just for you, being a specialist might pay a lot.
When a company is at need, it will pay obscene amounts of money for a
specialist to do "this thing right now!"
Just look at 2K bug madness. In case you are old enough to remember this stuff.
On the other hand,
specialist is limited in career choices. Once you have invested all that time
being Windows kernel expert, will you really move to be a PHP beginner
programmer? I guess not.
Generalist on the
other hand, can switch fields at will. I did that. I've ran Linux since 1996,
then moved to work at Microsoft. I've worked in storage then moved to access
and security, then returned to storage and now moved to security. Wait,
On the other hand,
from the money point of view, generalist can (usually) grow to be a bigger
manager than specialist. Again, usually and if she wants to. It is generally
easier to see a bigger picture when you are a generalist, which is a good
starting point for a manager. Actually, the truth is that the company will not
easily give up on specialist to turn him into another run-of-the-mill manager.
However, in either case, from the money perspective, being a manager pays off.
Taking all of this
into account, I decided to be both :) Since I am a generalist by nature, my
plan was to work as a generalist till I get to a point where it is hard for me
to find a new job. Then I will specialize in something. Most probably some
kernel. There are not much of kernel specialists and they are always in need.
In addition, it is relatively hard to become one. The best part is that
everyone expects the kernel guy to be over 50, not communicative and not to fit
Well, the problem
with my plan is the new places, like the one I'm in right now. Once I get to a
new place, my impostor
syndrome fears are multiplied by the generalist vs. specialists fears. Will
I keep up? How could I ever match up with this guy that knows so much? Can she
ever see me as her professional equal and come for advice?
Usually it works out
just fine. I also have my methods and cheats. The best one is to be always
It is actually
easier than it sounds. You just have to talk ONLY when you are 100% sure that
you are right. In all other times: shut up.
Another cheat is to
learn at night. This works especially good when there is a problem found
towards the end of the day. A meeting is set for tomorrow morning and everybody
goes home. Then you read about the issue and everything you can find for as
many hours as you could. At the morning meeting you definitely sounds like a
specialist (which is the goal).
I have a few more
cheats in my sleeve, but I always wonder if this time I will be exposed. If
this time, people will look at me and
say: "He does not know this! He is not as
good as we thought he will!"
I know that it
sounds preposterous, but I always fear that this time, it might happen …